Factual. Independent. Impartial.
Follow us
Scientists roast climate denier on cooling claim
feed_watermark
January 23, 2023
A US climate sceptic has gone viral on social media after pointing to official data that supposedly shows the planet has been cooling since 2015.
Steve Milloy, the founder of a blog called JunkScience.com, uses the data to declare "CO2 warming is a hoax".
But the claim is misleading, as the data it relies on is cherry-picked.
The base year used for the analysis, 2015, was a particularly hot year, meaning later years appear less warm by comparison. When any years prior to 2015 are added to the analysis, the data shows a clear trend of rising global temperatures.
On January 13, 2022, Mr Milloy tweeted a bar chart (archived here) that purportedly showed a fall in annual average global land and ocean temperatures in the years from 2015 to 2022.
Dozens of images of the tweet have been posted to Facebook, examples here, here and here.
The data used in the graph was taken from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), a US federal government agency responsible for climate monitoring.
Mr Milloy tweeted that the NOAA data "makes it official. Last 8 years... global cooling... despite 450+ billion tons of emissions worth 14% of total manmade CO2 in the atmosphere. CO2 warming is a hoax."
Mr Milloy is correct in saying there was a slight decrease in average global temperatures between 2015 and 2022.
However, 2015 was more than 0.2 degrees Celsius hotter than any prior year, making it an abnormally high base from which to compare temperatures in later years.
Setting the base as any year prior to 2015 results in a clear upward trend.
The bar chart's limited timeframe also obscures the fact that the years from 2015 to 2022 were the eight hottest years on record.
The full version of the NOAA dataset used for Mr Milloy's bar chart is plotted below, with the years 2015-2022 highlighted in red.
On January 15, NASA climate scientist Dr Christopher M. Colose responded on Twitter (archived here) to what he described as Mr Milloy's "disinformation".
"What he (Mr Milloy) didn't want to show you is that a warming system with variability will periodically exhibit short-term trends with pauses or accelerations in warming, but the long-term trends is up," the tweet read.
Dr Colose told AAP FactCheck that Mr Milloy's claim about global cooling was "as silly as saying that since the sun is going down at nighttime, you're entering a prolonged period of darkening and should cancel future outdoor picnics".
"If he (Mr Milloy) had tested for statistical significance, or picked nine or 10 or 11 years, he wouldn't be able to show the same result," Dr Colose said in an email.
"There are many people, including me, that will make wagers on whether the 2030s will be warmer than the 2020s, etc., but no one seems willing to take us up on it," Dr Colose said.
Other scientists also weighed in to debunk claims the earth is cooling.
On January 17, Berkeley Earth lead scientist Dr Robert Rohde tweeted (archive here): "If it is not literally the warmest year ever, someone will complain that global warming has stopped".
Dr Rohde's tweet included a graphic that showed regular short-term fluctuations in global temperatures since 1970 but a more consistent longer-term upward trend.
In August 2022, NOAA climatologist Ahira Snchez-Lugo told USA TODAY the purported post-2015 'cooling trend' was mostly due to temporary warming or cooling phases commonly known as El Nio and La Nia.
Other false and misleading claims about alleged global cooling, based on cherry-picked short-term data, have been fact-checked here, here and here.
Sources
Fact-checking is a team effort
Every AAP FactCheck article is the result of a meticulous process involving numerous experienced journalists and producers. Our articles are thoroughly researched, carefully crafted and rigorously scrutinised to ensure the highest standard of accuracy and objectivity in every piece.
AAP FactCheck is an accredited member of the International Fact-Checking Network
